Investigation finds advisers coaching asylum seekers to feign sexuality

An investigation has found that some immigration advisers are coaching asylum seekers to falsely claim they are gay to secure protection and remain in the country, raising concerns about the integrity of the asylum system and the safeguards meant to protect vulnerable people.

According to the findings, certain advisers allegedly instruct applicants on personal narratives, mannerisms, or fabricated evidence designed to meet criteria for protection based on sexual orientation. Such coaching can distort credibility assessments and risks placing genuine LGBTQ+ claimants under heightened suspicion, potentially leading to longer processing times and more intrusive questioning for all applicants.

In many jurisdictions, persecution on the grounds of sexual orientation is recognised as a basis for refugee status. Adjudicators typically evaluate detailed interviews, consistency across statements, and any corroborating material. While qualified advisers can play a vital role in guiding applicants through complex procedures, they also have a duty to uphold ethical and legal standards that ensure claims are truthful and fairly presented.

The revelations are likely to fuel calls for tighter oversight of immigration advice services, firmer enforcement against misconduct, and better training for caseworkers to evaluate claims without relying on stereotypes. Advocacy groups say any reforms must balance fraud prevention with safeguarding people who face real harm if returned.